Contractor Calculator
Umbrella Company vs Limited Company 2026/27: The Full Financial Comparison
At £500 per day outside IR35, a limited company takes home £72,765 in 2026/27. An umbrella company at the same rate gives you £67,065. That’s a £5,700 gap — but once you subtract accountancy fees, insurance, and admin overhead, the real advantage is closer to £3,000–£4,500. Whether that’s worth the extra complexity depends on your rate, your IR35 status, and how much you value a simple life.
Compare your exact take-home across all structures →
Key facts (2026/27, outside IR35, 232 working days):
- Ltd company at £500/day: £72,765 take-home
- Umbrella at £500/day: £67,065 take-home
- Gross difference: £5,700/year
- Net difference after Ltd costs (£1,500–£2,500/year): £3,200–£4,200/year
Take-home comparison at four day rates
All figures assume 232 working days, outside IR35, £12,570 salary (Ltd) or standard umbrella deductions with a 2% margin.
| Day rate | Annual gross | Ltd company | Umbrella | Ltd advantage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| £350/day | £81,200 | £57,481 | £52,891 | £4,590 |
| £400/day | £92,800 | £61,810 | £55,709 | £6,101 |
| £500/day | £116,000 | £72,765 | £67,065 | £5,700 |
| £600/day | £139,200 | £83,721 | £78,321 | £5,400 |
The Ltd company advantage is real at every rate — but it’s not unlimited. The gap is largest around £400–£500/day. At higher rates, personal allowance tapering and the shift into higher dividend tax bands shrink the premium slightly.
On a £500/day rate, running a limited company keeps you roughly £475 more per month. After a £2,000 accountancy fee, that’s around £300/month in your pocket.
The real Ltd company cost
The take-home figures above don’t account for the overhead of running a limited company. These are the typical annual costs:
| Cost | Typical range |
|---|---|
| Accountancy fees | £1,500–£3,000 |
| Professional Indemnity insurance | £200–£500 |
| Companies House confirmation statement | £34 |
| Business bank account | £0–£120 |
| Total annual overhead | £1,750–£3,650 |
At £500/day, the gross Ltd advantage is £5,700. After £2,000 in costs, the net advantage is £3,700/year — still significant, but less dramatic than the headline figure suggests.
Below roughly £325/day, the maths gets tight. The Ltd premium shrinks to around £3,000–£4,000, and after costs of £2,000+, you’re keeping under £2,000 extra per year for the admin of running a company. At that point, the simplicity of an umbrella is worth considering — especially for short contracts.
Inside IR35: the comparison changes completely
If your contract is inside IR35, the limited company advantage shrinks to near zero. Both structures tax your income as employment income. The main difference:
- Umbrella inside IR35: employer NI deducted from your fee, income tax and employee NI applied via PAYE. Simple and compliant.
- Ltd company inside IR35: you take a deemed salary, pay employer NI, income tax, and employee NI — with the added cost of running a company that gives you almost no tax benefit.
At £500/day inside IR35, both structures give you approximately £66,500–£67,500 take-home. The Ltd company costs you an extra £1,500–£2,500/year in accountancy with nothing to show for it.
Inside IR35, an umbrella company is almost always the right answer unless you have specific reasons to keep your Ltd company active (e.g., outside-IR35 work in the pipeline).
When a limited company is clearly the right choice
- You’re outside IR35 on a rate above £350/day
- You plan to contract for 12+ months
- You’re comfortable with quarterly/annual admin (or have an accountant who handles it)
- You want to control your pension strategy through employer contributions
- You’re above £100k and want to use salary sacrifice to manage the personal allowance taper
When an umbrella company makes more sense
- Your contract is inside IR35
- You’re on a short engagement (under 3–6 months) and don’t want to set up a company for it
- Your day rate is below £325–£350 and the tax saving doesn’t justify the overhead
- You’re new to contracting and want to understand the market before committing to a Ltd company
- You’re between contracts and want to close down cleanly
The switching cost
Moving from Ltd to umbrella is straightforward — you keep your Ltd dormant (£13/year to HMRC to confirm dormancy) or close it (Members’ Voluntary Liquidation if there are significant reserves, or informal strike-off if not). Going the other way — umbrella to Ltd — requires setting up a company, registering for Corporation Tax, sorting payroll, and finding an accountant. Budget 2–4 weeks and £500–£800 in setup costs.
How is this calculated?
Limited company figures use: £12,570 salary, 15% employer NI on earnings above £5,000, Corporation Tax with marginal relief (19–25%), dividend tax at 10.75% (basic) and 35.75% (higher rate), with a £500 dividend allowance. Umbrella figures use a 2% margin (industry standard for compliant providers) plus employer NI at 15%, Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5%, employee NI at 8%/2%, and income tax at the appropriate bands. Both use 2026/27 HMRC rates.
Frequently asked questions
Is a limited company always better than an umbrella?
Outside IR35, yes — at rates above ~£325/day. The tax saving is real and substantial. Inside IR35, no — both structures give similar take-home, but the umbrella is simpler and cheaper to run.
How much do I save with a limited company vs umbrella?
At £500/day outside IR35, the gross saving is £5,700/year. After accountancy fees and insurance (typically £1,750–£3,000/year), the net saving is roughly £2,700–£3,950/year. At £400/day, the gross saving is £6,101 — slightly higher, because more dividends fall in the basic rate band.
Can I use both — umbrella for some contracts and Ltd for others?
Yes. Many contractors keep their Ltd company dormant during inside-IR35 or short contracts and use an umbrella instead. The Ltd company continues to exist with minimal admin and cost. When you land an outside-IR35 contract, you reactivate it. This is common practice and entirely legitimate.
Does the umbrella company choice affect my take-home?
Yes. Umbrella margins vary from 1% to 5%+ of your fee. A compliant FCSA-accredited provider typically charges 1–2.5%. On a £500/day rate, moving from a 1% margin to a 3% margin costs you around £2,320/year. Always check the full deduction breakdown before signing. Calculate umbrella take-home with any margin →
What about IR35 reform — will the rules change?
The current off-payroll rules (Chapter 10, ITEPA 2003) have been in place since 2021 for the private sector. There’s no announced plan to reverse them. If anything, the introduction of Joint and Several Liability rules in April 2026 signals continued government focus on compliance in the contractor supply chain — not a relaxation of IR35.
Not sure which structure gives you the best take-home at your rate? Use our free Compare Structures calculator — it shows Ltd company, umbrella, inside IR35, and sole trader side by side in seconds.